<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> <rss
version="2.0" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"> <channel><title>Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title> <description> Assalamu alaykum,
I am writing to seek your esteemed opinion and enlightened guidance regarding a matter that is weighing heavily on my heart, concerning the ritual sacrifice of Eid al-Adha. As a student residing in France, I find myself in a unique situation that prompts me to question the obligation of performing the sacrifice given my current circumstances.
Allow me to provide some background on my situation. I am living in a shared accommodation with my younger sister, separated from my divorced parents. My mother and stepfather reside abroad and do not financially support me, although they are available to assist me in case of financial difficulties (Alhamdulillah, I have not faced such difficulties thus far). My father and stepmother live in France and provide me with a monthly allowance of 100 euros for groceries, while my expenses amount to approximately 250 euros. I am solely responsible for other expenses, including rent and medical costs. Additionally, I have a significant amount of money in my bank account as I plan my finances one year in advance, ensuring that the funds currently available will be utilized for the upcoming year and beyond. Purchasing a sacrificial animal would have a negative financial impact on my situation for the following year.
In light of these circumstances, I find myself in a predicament as to whether I should proceed with the ritual sacrifice. I seek to make an informed decision, considering both religious teachings and my financial responsibilities.
Furthermore, I would like to mention that both my stepfather and my father have planned to perform their own sacrifices for Eid al-Adha.
It is within this context that I humbly request your advice and guidance. Given my current financial situation, would it be recommended or preferable for me to also perform a sacrifice, while hoping that it will not compromise my finances for the upcoming year, inshaAllah?
I sincerely appreciate your attention and support, and I implore Allah to grant you wisdom and clarity in guiding me through this decision.
May the peace and blessings of Allah be upon you.
Assalamu alaykum,</description><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890452.html#msg-11890452</link> <lastBuildDate>Fri, 05 Jun 2026 15:54:42 +0200</lastBuildDate> <generator>Phorum 5.2.15</generator> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-12367192.html#msg-12367192</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-12367192.html#msg-12367192</link> <description><![CDATA[ Wa alaykum salam bro, thanks for sharing so honestly. Tbh, with your situation, it doesn’t sound like you’re financially obligated to do the sacrifice. Islam isn’t meant to burden us, and your intention matters. You’re planning ahead and...]]></description> <dc:creator>elsasmith</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Mon, 07 Jul 2025 13:55:17 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890663.html#msg-11890663</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890663.html#msg-11890663</link> <description><![CDATA[ Thé source of what ?
There is a religious section here and most of people are muslims living in France.  But it's notre a religious site. But you can have some tips on islam or anything else about France, life, help, your studies etc
...]]></description> <dc:creator>Karimov75</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 12:54:00 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890620.html#msg-11890620</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890620.html#msg-11890620</link> <description><![CDATA[ Could you give me the source in french please]]></description> <dc:creator>Abdellah7852</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 11:18:47 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890618.html#msg-11890618</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890618.html#msg-11890618</link> <description><![CDATA[ Thank you for your answers, I also asked a man of science in religion but I'm not sure to have an answer before the feast of aid hence my post. Not to mention that I thought this site was devoted to religious matters, but I made a mistake, in any...]]></description> <dc:creator>Abdellah7852</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 11:17:02 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890499.html#msg-11890499</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890499.html#msg-11890499</link> <description><![CDATA[ Il va y avoir la queue devant son bureau alors lol
Mais tu as raison (tu) je disais ça plus dans le sens où ce sont des choses que tu peux apprendre 'partout' c'est pas comme si tu avais une situation compliquée ou litigieuse et ne sait pas...]]></description> <dc:creator>Karimov75</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 01:51:05 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890498.html#msg-11890498</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890498.html#msg-11890498</link> <description><![CDATA[ Salam,
Je n′ai pas dit que c′était une question qui faisait débat,  mais de demander la prochaine fois à un homme de science s'il a d′autres questions en rapport avec la religion. Le forum traite bien divers types de sujet, mais pour les...]]></description> <dc:creator>Hellaaa</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 01:47:13 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890494.html#msg-11890494</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890494.html#msg-11890494</link> <description><![CDATA[ Salam
C'est même pas une question qui fait débat ici... Le seul qui a l'obligation de faire le sacrifice c'est l'aisé, à savoir celui qui en a les moyens après répondu à TOUS ses besoins ( ceux de ses proches evidemment) et avec de...]]></description> <dc:creator>Karimov75</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 01:39:21 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890487.html#msg-11890487</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890487.html#msg-11890487</link> <description><![CDATA[ Waleykum Salam,
As a student, and considering your critical fnancial state, you don′t need to perform a sacrifice for Eid but you can give alms. Although, I′ll suggest you to directly ask a person of science like a mufti for further...]]></description> <dc:creator>Hellaaa</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 01:08:20 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890483.html#msg-11890483</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890483.html#msg-11890483</link> <description><![CDATA[ C'est mieux que ça... il va à la mosquée et il doit demander à ce qu'on lui donne une part ! Dayza fi8 !
Si on donne pas à des personnes comme lui merci de m'expliquer à qui il faut fonner lol
Non seulement il est étudiant mais...]]></description> <dc:creator>Karimov75</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 00:54:23 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890478.html#msg-11890478</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890478.html#msg-11890478</link> <description><![CDATA[ Alaikum salam,
You can't afford it so don't worry about it. Go to the Eid prayer though and prepare some nice food for you and your sister, celebrate that day inshaAllah. As mentioned above, when you'll be working and can afford it, then yes...]]></description> <dc:creator>whysoseriousssah</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 00:45:11 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890474.html#msg-11890474</guid><title>Re: Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452-11890474.html#msg-11890474</link> <description><![CDATA[ Salam
You're à student ?  So you don't work ans live by the money of other peoples !  How can you pay any taxes to the country firt, to  poor people ( wich is one of the 5 BIGGEST obligation for islam)?  So why do you think that you have to...]]></description> <dc:creator>Karimov75</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 00:33:36 +0200</pubDate> </item> <item> <guid>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452.html</guid><title>Sacrifice Aid Kabir for student</title><link>//en.yabiladi.com/topics/sacrifice-kabir-student-44-11890452.html</link> <description><![CDATA[ Assalamu alaykum,
I am writing to seek your esteemed opinion and enlightened guidance regarding a matter that is weighing heavily on my heart, concerning the ritual sacrifice of Eid al-Adha. As a student residing in France, I find myself in a...]]></description> <dc:creator>Abdellah7852</dc:creator> <category>Morocco # English board</category> <pubDate>Fri, 23 Jun 2023 00:07:10 +0200</pubDate> </item> </channel> </rss>